Parliament Cafeteria - 21 October 07

Parliament Cafeteria with Javed Hashmi, Faisal Saleh Hayaat and Naseem Zahra hosted by Asma Chaudhry.

Email This Article - News - Video Email This Article - News - Video

76 Comments »

  1. comment-top

    admin dude
    there is not video with this post, just a heading. Do you forget to attach video.

    comment-bottom
  2. comment-top

    @Naveed,

    Video is being uploaded to viddler. Did you forgot to read the text in the post.

    Admin

    comment-bottom
  3. comment-top

    I am not sure this announcement is good thing or not. But I think if someone is planning to go out or sleep in next 20-30 minutes should be able to know what is coming next and can decide accordingly.

    Video should be ready in 10 minutes. Jawab Deh, Focus with Faeza and Meray Mutabiq lined up for tonight.

    Admin

    comment-bottom
  4. comment-top

    Have some patience and appreciation for the jb the admin is doing.

    comment-bottom
  5. comment-top

    Admin
    Pease don’t mind some people for being impatient. Like many I am sure this announcement helps us to set a schedule, so please keep it up.
    Thanks

    comment-bottom
  6. comment-top

    @admin

    I appreciate ur patience man, ppl take things for granted and think that its their right to push you to upload things as they want.
    Hard & gud work by you, keep it up.

    comment-bottom
  7. Nadeem Sheikh Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 12:49 pm
    comment-top

    Admin,

    The time stamp that appears with comments is a bit misleading. Can you please clarify whether this is PAK or UK time. I know you are busy with more useful work but a clarification will be appreciated.

    comment-bottom
  8. comment-top

    Video uploaded.

    Admin

    comment-bottom
  9. comment-top

    Sallam Admin,

    Can U tell me that Is there anychance to Upload Jawab Deyh with Ehsan Iqbal.

    Thanks

    Shahid Ch

    comment-bottom
  10. comment-top

    aoa

    @admin

    keep up the good work and most of us are patient thnx.

    comment-bottom
  11. comment-top

    Yaar yeh kasi Ancor haa … I don’t understand why she have to interrupt each and everyone … let the guest complete his phrase.

    comment-bottom
  12. Javed I. Sheikh Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 1:29 pm
    comment-top

    PPP leadership named a few persons, who could be involved in the Karachi Bomb Blast. Why not to put those persons under a Polygraph Test?

    comment-bottom
  13. comment-top

    Why BB is taking all the trouble of putting her life in danger and at the same risking so many innocent lives.She has been already tried twice,her govt was a total failure.Her govt was so corrupt,that her own party man.the then President,Farooq Khan Leghari was compelled to dismiss her govt.She should be ashamed to ask for vote from the people of Pakistan.Her husband was famous as Mr 10%,Now is he looking to be named as Mr 25%.Her own brother was killed,during her own regime.

    comment-bottom
  14. comment-top

    there is no role of women in politics, as a Muslim we should condemn that. We don’t need Benazir to rule our Islamic country. Is is not allowed in Islam
    Also in my opinion the shows should be hosted by a male anchor as Islam does not allow women to be in politics.
    May Allah guide us on right path.

    @admin
    Brother I think you should have a censor policy and should not post any political talk show which has woman in it.

    comment-bottom
  15. comment-top

    The future of politicians in Pakistan amidst the awam kush army and khood kush religious fanatics.
    http://www.jang.com.pk/jang/oct2007-daily/21-10-2007/col4.htm

    comment-bottom
  16. comment-top

    Admin you are doing a great job, me and all my friends everyday watch this great website and it’s the only source for us to keep in touch with discussion
    thanks
    Khalid
    Michigan,USA

    comment-bottom
  17. comment-top

    @Admn

    I must appreciate your efforts. Your dedication to this site, especially when it is not even earning for you, is amazing. Keep it up brother/sister, JazakAllah.

    comment-bottom
  18. comment-top

    Great efforts admn

    comment-bottom
  19. comment-top

    @Naveed

    Ho hum….

    Since you are so learned about Islam, please quote me from where are you saying that women are not supposed to enter politics?

    I have not come across this in the holy Quran. I believe we have the same Quran, don’t we?

    Arsalan

    comment-bottom
  20. comment-top

    Quite a pathetic anchorperson.

    comment-bottom
  21. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 2:43 pm
    comment-top

    Navid, Please quote Quran or Hadith where women has been ban from entering Public life. Prophet Mushammad’s wife was business women.

    comment-bottom
  22. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 2:44 pm
    comment-top

    And yes Navid another wife of Prophet Muhammad was Commander in Chief of Army.

    comment-bottom
  23. comment-top

    traffic

    comment-bottom
  24. Javed I. Sheikh Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 2:50 pm
    comment-top

    @ Arsalan,
    Even Maulana Modoodi, (the Poineer of Terrorism in the sub-continent), supported Mohtarma Fatima Jinnah when she cotested the election agianst Gen. Ayub Khan.
    Mr. Naveed should be aware of History.
    I wait, when he declares Maulana Modoodi, an infidel, for supporting a woman in politics.

    comment-bottom
  25. comment-top

    @admin

    came across this intersting short discussion with dr. shahid masood. please embed this here.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8g9PvqFla7w

    thanks

    comment-bottom
  26. comment-top

    @Naveed

    Not wanting Benazir to rule the country has got nothing to do with her gender. Women have no role in politics? And that you say has got to do with Islam? You nauseate me! Please study Islam before passing sweeping statements about the religion.

    As for female anchor persons, what trouble do you have with them? If your “imaan” is endangered by looking at them, please don’t watch the show. Its people like you with a tunnel vision approach who are the demise of Pakistan and Islam. The trouble is with your own mind which cannot see a woman as a person but a specimen of her species.

    comment-bottom
  27. comment-top

    @Shahid,

    Geo repeated Jawab Deyh with Qazi Hussain again today. When and in which country did you see with Ahsan Iqbal?

    Admin

    comment-bottom
  28. comment-top

    @naveed

    Bro, you need some serious counseling. Its people like you who have made a simple religion like Islam confusing for others. I can write on and on arguing everthing you have said about islam and women. But like I said, you need some serious help with your ideologies and knowledge of Islam.

    comment-bottom
  29. comment-top

    The problem is that
    On the table
    Two are Shia
    One Celebrity
    And One is Sunni Syed
    What should NATIVES do?
    When would we be asked, what we want.
    The Stock Markets, Media, Parties, Talk Shows, Businesses all is dominated by minorities.
    What about Majorities, their voices.
    That is why they explode and not talk.

    comment-bottom
  30. comment-top

    aoa

    javed hashmi was saying ns will be back in country next month i cannot see this happening because it will be end of q league

    comment-bottom
  31. comment-top

    I am 100% agree with Naveed. Women have no role outside her home unless it’s really needed. It is very clear in Islam that best place for women is her home and family.
    Please don’t just start argue because you don’t follow Islam as it has been told to us. Most of us just pick and choose things from Islam.

    comment-bottom
  32. comment-top

    @ syed khan

    Get a life my friend.

    comment-bottom
  33. Amir Hameed Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 4:07 pm
    comment-top

    @Naveed,
    You should read Quran with translation so that you know what Quran says and stop visiting and listening to the sham & half-baked Islami scholers because this is exactly what they preach.

    comment-bottom
  34. comment-top

    wanted to share this:
    i like aaj tv shows better!
    http://www.viddler.com/explore/GeoKanjarTv/videos/13/

    comment-bottom
  35. comment-top

    @ Sahi

    Please go and read the Quran. It is btw, the same for sunnis and shias and the rest of the world.

    It says, and I will translate as closely as I can.

    “To take an innocent life is like killing all humanity”

    That means killing every human being on earth. So be ashamed that you had the nerve to come and defend this heinous attack.

    Btw, please enlighten me whether our holy prophet followed any particular sect? Was he Shia or Sunni? Barelvi? Deobandi maybe?

    @ Syed Khan

    So my dear Syed Khan, you would want your wife to deliver her baby with Male Gyneacolgists? Would you want your daughters to saty ignorant all their lives because people like you keep blowing up girls schools in their enlightened vision of utopia for muslims where women are no better than the cows and the sheep in the barn next door? Would you want your muslim sisters, all 600 million of them to remain goofs and unproductive? Why, can you explain to me, you and the @naveeds of this world that God gave them also a fully functional brain if they were never meant to use them? Where in God’s name have you read that women are forbidden to go outside their homes? Where exactly in the Quran? WHERE???

    P.S. I am not talking about the concept of Purdah. Just the mere fact that you disagree with women going out of their homes for anything worthwhile.

    comment-bottom
  36. comment-top

    @ Naveed
    Re: on the role of women in Islam.

    Imam of Lal Masjid even changed his gender and wore a burqa when he recently tried to escape and was captured during the mutiny.

    comment-bottom
  37. comment-top

    @ Naveed
    Re: On the role of women of Islam

    The taleban in Afghanistan refused to allow women to wear high heels–as this action would have “an equal and opposite reaction” amongst the imaandar.

    @ Admin
    What happened to the moderators who are supposed to put these discussants in garbage.

    comment-bottom
  38. comment-top

    Quote:
    _____________
    there is no role of women in politics, as a Muslim we should condemn that. We don’t need Benazir to rule our Islamic country. Is is not allowed in Islam
    ______________
    Bigotry has no limits. Pakistan is not ruled by anarchists. It has a constitution. There is a consensus in this nation on role of women in politics.

    Those who think women as less humans do not deserve any respect. Islam has a great role of women and give women equal rights. Their opinion is very important. That is the reason Hadhrat Aisha was the bigest contributeor of Hadeeths. She led an army of sahaba in War of Jamal. Was she less human? Was she less intelligent?

    If Sahaba didn’t object who are you naveed? I consider your comments highly objectionable, blasphemic to Islam, and rude to women. From me a slap on face and kick on back.

    comment-bottom
  39. comment-top

    Quote:
    __________
    On the table
    Two are Shia
    One Celebrity
    And One is Sunni Syed
    What should NATIVES do?
    ___________

    Thanks god there is no Wahabi or deobandi on the table.

    Pakistanie are PAKISTANIES first. They are all equal and all have same rights. Thanks god Pakistan is not Saudia.

    comment-bottom
  40. comment-top

    @ saqibtahir

    Good arguments my friend. but as i mentioned above, no use to even argue with people who follow such ideologies and completely misunderstand Islam.

    - “From me a slap on face and kick on back.”

    Kindly accept a package of slaps and kicks from me as well.

    comment-bottom
  41. comment-top

    Quote:
    ____________
    Women have no role outside her home unless it’s really needed. It is very clear in Islam that best place for women is her home and family.
    _____________
    Don’t mix Islam with Wahabism. Even Wahabi women are now working outside their home. Go and see today’s Saudia.

    comment-bottom
  42. comment-top

    Using religion card against popular Muslim leaders is not new. Muslims in general are moderate and hate violance in the name of God. Unfortunately Muslim clergy and ruling class always try to shelter behind Islam to save their backs from the poor masses. Religion card was used against Quaid Azam, Sir Syed, Iqbal, Shahee Bhutto. During 1970 elections A Fatwa of Kufr was issued against Bhutto by Whabi - Saudi clergy to favour Moudoodi. Outside Pakistan same Saudi sponsored Mullas issued Kufr fatwas agains Jamal Nasir of Egypt, Soekarno of Indonesia, Ben Bela of Algeria, Yaser Arfat of Palistine, Baathists from Syria and Iraq, leaders of Iran revolution and so on.

    No matter Fundos like it or not, BB has proved herself to be the most popular leader of this nation.

    comment-bottom
  43. comment-top

    Quote
    ____________
    Imam of Lal Masjid even changed his gender and wore a burqa when he recently tried to escape and was captured during the mutiny.
    ___________
    Look at his face too. He can get a role in ‘planet of apes’.

    comment-bottom
  44. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 10:51 pm
    comment-top

    Syed Khan, I follow and practics Islam as it has been toll to us. I have bread according to sunna of Prophet and not according to Qazi Hussain or Maulana F. who keep beard according to Sunna of Abu Jahal.

    Syes Khan can you quote me one Quran Ayat or Hadith which debare women in public life.

    comment-bottom
  45. comment-top

    I wonder why they made sure that BB should stay alive while poor, slave like Sindhis should be killed en mass.
    MQM
    Is Terrorist.
    Or
    We should assume that the kids who are being butchered by Musharaf and Co could not waste such an opportunity without retribution.
    For those who wish to through slurs,
    I know
    Barking D@gs
    Seldom Bite

    comment-bottom
  46. comment-top

    Quote:
    ___________
    Navid, Please quote Quran or Hadith where women has been ban from entering Public life. Prophet Mushammad’s wife was business women.
    ____________
    100% right. I would add one thing. Prophet Muhammad was an employee of Hadrat Khadeeja. second. By all standards it was a love marriage. Third Hadrat Khadeeja was the main financial support of our prophet for years before and after he got prophethood because he was not working himself.

    comment-bottom
  47. comment-top

    @ Naveed
    @ Syed Khan

    You are pathetic to even degrade the role of women in Islam. The religion is so tolerant as to accept the khusras (like your mentors) as equal members of society.

    I suggest you pay attention to and discuss the “munafiq” regime of the House of Saud–when there is no concept of kingship in Islam.

    comment-bottom
  48. Al Zulfiqar Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 10:59 pm
    comment-top

    wtf is wrong with this host, she keep cutting off the guests… cmn girl…. if u invite them let them speak..plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!

    comment-bottom
  49. comment-top

    my internet is slow at this time so i can not give u references right now, but tomorrow i will post a detail article on that. There are solid reasons behind it, even usa dont have any woman president.
    anyhoo, no need to wait for my response, go to ur local mosque and check it with Imam.

    comment-bottom
  50. comment-top

    @ Naveed

    - The front runner for the 2008 presidential elections in the USA is a woman!

    - All the young boys in the neighborhood have stopped going to the local mosque because they are scared of the imam.

    The only reason I am wasting my time through responding to your diatribe is again a hopeless hope to “nip the evil in the bud.”

    comment-bottom
  51. Amir Hameed Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 11:18 pm
    comment-top

    @Naveed,
    “There are solid reasons behind it, even usa dont have any woman president.”
    What does US not having a female president have anything to do with what you are suggesting?

    comment-bottom
  52. comment-top

    Their are three Psychological points
    After that the nation will go for
    Complete Revolution for Democracy
    First, The Judges have to decide, whether they support Democracy or Hippocracy.
    Then
    Musharaf have to Shed the the warmth of Uniform.
    Then
    A rigged election has to happen.
    I Am Optimistic.
    That all would happen and would be Revolted by
    Nawaz
    Imran
    Qazi
    Lawyers
    And
    The soles of innocents killed in Islamabad, Karachi (12 May) and FATA.
    Then Our Army would surrender,
    To the the will of the Majorities.
    Then BB would go back for ever.
    SOON

    comment-bottom
  53. comment-top

    @ democrat bro

    “nip the evil in the bud.

    comment-bottom
  54. comment-top

    wow guys, looks like musharraga did the trick.
    enlightened moderation :)

    just go and read some islamic books. not musharraf islam

    comment-bottom
  55. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 21st, 2007 at 11:35 pm
    comment-top

    Naveed, Please reply the questions do not decide who is muslim and who is not it is not your job. And can you name books that you want us to read.

    Shahid Kinnare
    Memphis TN

    901370-5779

    kinnare2001@yahoo.com

    comment-bottom
  56. comment-top

    @ Naveed

    I can now fully understand where you are coming from. You are a young (still without a beard) refugee from Lal Masjid in Islamabad.

    But that now you have access to the computer and the internet, you can start learning some skills to become a productive member of the society.

    Please don’t start reciting the old lessons those mullahs taught you while you were sitting in their laps. Shun the past!

    comment-bottom
  57. comment-top

    Some Sunni haters are at loose on this forum,
    Some in Baghdad
    Some in Kabul
    But
    They live in Fools Paradise.

    comment-bottom
  58. comment-top

    @ Sahi

    @ Admin
    This is NOT a religious site. Please delete Sahi’s negative remarks above. Thank you.

    comment-bottom
  59. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 22nd, 2007 at 12:49 am
    comment-top

    Sahi, this is not about shia or sunni. I myself is sunni, but cannot agree with people like Navid. Pakistan is for Pakistanies not for shia or sunnies.

    comment-bottom
  60. Javed I. Sheikh Says:
    October 22nd, 2007 at 1:10 am
    comment-top

    Case # 786

    Maulvi Fazal-Ul-Rahman Vs. Mullah Qazi Husain
    Verdict:

    RAQS-I MAEY TEZ KARO, SAZ KI LAEY TAZ KARO
    SOO-I MAIKHANA FAQEERAN-I HARAM AATEY HEIN

    comment-bottom
  61. comment-top

    pakistan was made for muslims. hence i agree with my friends that it should have a sunni rule and no woman leadship

    comment-bottom
  62. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 22nd, 2007 at 2:01 am
    comment-top

    Khurram, Pakistan was not made for muslim. Lahore resolution does not mention Pakistan would muslim state. Second Jinnah was Ismailies an as we all know that Ismailies are Kafir. This the reason Mulla of India use to call Pakistan Kafirstan and Jinnah Kafir. Major investor for Pakistan Movement was Sir Sultan Mohammad Shah who again was Kafir. Third their are muslim in India then in Pakistan so according to your logic India is also mulsim country. Pakistan is for Pakistanies no matter wheter they are Muslim, Hindu, Christain, Ismailies, Ahamdiyas, Bhories.

    comment-bottom
  63. comment-top


    Naveed, Please reply the questions do not decide who is muslim and who is not it is not your job. And can you name books that you want us to read.

    Shahid Kinnare
    Memphis TN

    901370-5779

    who are you to say ismali are kafir? do u even know the meaning of that word. and please read history.
    Pakistan wasnt only meant for muslims. but it was definitely meant to be a islamic state.

    comment-bottom
  64. comment-top

    Quote:
    ___________
    Some Sunni haters are at loose on this forum,
    __________
    Those whose religion is hate can see nothing but hate. 80% of Pakistanies are Sunni.

    comment-bottom
  65. comment-top

    Shahid, You and your Wahabi friends have exposed yourself by calling Quaid-e-Azam as Kafir. Remember Jinnah is our hero and his ideology is our faith. You better go to your hell in Topra Bora and sleep with your goat.

    comment-bottom
  66. comment-top

    Sahi, I promise that you will die, your children will die and children of your children will die and no one will even remember your grave but your Wahabi revolution will not happen. Remember we sunnies wash our mosques when a wahabi put his dirty foot in it?

    comment-bottom
  67. comment-top

    @ Khurram, @ Naveed
    Quote
    ___________________________________________
    “pakistan was made for muslims. hence i agree with my friends that it should have a sunni rule and no woman leadship”
    ___________________________________________

    It was your Sunni leader: Maulana Maudoodi who nominated and supported Fatima Jinnah as the head of Opposition Parties in the 1964 presidential candidate against Ayub Khan. Thus, Maudoodi was a “munafiq” and he and his believers deserve to die without delay.

    comment-bottom
  68. comment-top

    @ Saqibtahir, Sahi:

    I am convinced that the mullahs have wrecked the brains of potential suicide bombers like Naveed and Sahi. “Muslims brainwashed to kill muslims”. Subhanallah for Lal Masjid.

    So, the only way to to crush cockraoaches.

    comment-bottom
  69. comment-top

    @Naveed
    no need to wait for my response, go to ur local mosque and check it with Imam.

    Please ask any Muslim scholar of your choice who would say that is it allowed for men or women to touch or even come close to each other
    like BB and Sherry Rehman were doing in the parade.

    comment-bottom
  70. comment-top

    We are Muslim first then Pakistani then Sindhi or Punjabi. Please try to read Constitution.
    It is ‘Islamic Republic of Pakistan’.

    comment-bottom
  71. shahid kinnare Says:
    October 22nd, 2007 at 4:44 am
    comment-top

    I am not saying that Ismailies are kafir I am only quoting from History.

    comment-bottom
  72. comment-top

    @ Syed Khan @ Naveed @Khurram Khan

    - According to your preference, only men should touch and be close to other men. Saudi Arabia is number one in “hum jinsi”!

    - So, there is no room for other ethnic groupings and religions in your warped state of mind as suicide bombers. Do you know the meaning of “republic”? Go, kill yourself!

    comment-bottom
  73. comment-top

    @Democrat
    Do you know the meaning of “republic

    comment-bottom
  74. comment-top

    @ Syed Khan @ Khurram

    I am referring to your warped minds and training. Just wait for the Mukti Bahini!

    comment-bottom
  75. comment-top

    @ Naveed, Syed Khan

    Get one thing clear in your little pea of a brain, YOUR interpretation of Islam is not necessarily the right interpretation. Moreover, it is not for YOU to decide what is right for a woman and what is not. Islam gave her this right 1400 years ago. Yes, a married womans’ prime responsibility is her home but there can be some women who happen to have more capabilities than your limited ones and are fully capable of doing other things as well. This arrangement is strictly between a woman and her husband. Its not for any Tom, Dick and Harry like you to pass judgements on women.

    How the woman has to go out of the house is a separate discussion. There are some norms and requirements. The concept of hijab comes in play there. What would be very interesting for male chauvinists like you to note would probably be that Quran first mentions “hijab” for a man and then for a woman. Ever thought about your own duty? So if Sherry Rehman was “rubbing her shoulders against blah blah” why do you oggle at her? Where is your side of “hijab” in this? Does Islam give you the right to spread the video on Youtube and watch it and refer to it. Ever heard of punishment for disparaging the character of a owman in Islam? First guard your gaze and hold your tongue and THEN criticise other women you have no relation to. Shame on you!

    Get one thig clear. West is not our ideal for women liberation. Islam liberated women centuries ago and we do not need any models of “enlightened moderation” for freedom. Its just people like you, for whom Islam just means confining women to homes so that you can tyrannize them and treat them like cattle, that make things so comlicated. I know the Islam where women were surgeons, where women debated with the prophet, where women accosted the khalifa in public gatherings, where women joined in congregational prayers, where women had the right to their own income and property and were useful thinking and productive members of society, not the vegetative look-pretty-do-nothing beings that you like to see them as.

    I strongly urge you to read the following books that I am referring. I think of it as my duty to invite people like you to better ideas. Who knows you may change your mind. Maybe, non Muslims who convert to islam are better Muslims than us because they see religion without the ethnic and cultural prejudices that blind our eyes. Especially in Pakistan, the Hindu influence has done so much harm because Hinduism treats women as lesser beings.

    Struggling to Surrender by Jeffrey Lang
    Road to Mecca by Mohammad Asad
    Even Angels Ask by Jeffrey Lang.

    Also read the tafseer of Quran written by Mohammad Asad. When reading tafseer, please refer to a no of scholars because a tafseer is after all in interpretation and you need to know different views to be able to come to a conclusion. Broaden your vision please and look beyond the prejudices you were raised in.

    comment-bottom
  76. comment-top

    @admin,
    where this conversation is going ???
    bhai plz do something to the ppl who induldged themselves in hatered for a particular nation,sect,religion,or in that case for a particular gender….
    no2.they all left the parliament cafe afr away …and have started women rights conference here….
    no3.Ahsan Iqbal ,jawabdeh was air last night on oct21st ,sunday at 8 to 9 according to PAK standard time….

    comment-bottom

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.