allah & wahy have nothing to do with collective life, state, society,social sector or politics.

Religion is a personal matter . We shold atleast become good human being.
Jinnah was the most secular person Remember his first speech to constiruent assembly.

Additionally, the fact that the program is an old one has no bearing on whether it’s a useful discussion to have or not, these days. This is a topical issue which, like any classical discussion, always has, and always will, affect peoples’ lives on an everyday basis. Hence the relevance.

@ Javed.

Problem with you is that , you cannot come out of your tunnnel vision. Grow up now. Try to give logics.
You have not read my comments completly.
I said unfortunately we dont have any leader having some qualities of JINNAH.
Thisinclude BB and NS as well. BB and NS ARE NOT SIANTS and are not beyond criticism . They have their faults.

These programmes are so Punjab oriented and Punjab centered (with some figures from urban Sindh and NWFP once in a while), with Punjabi politicians dominating the shows, to the point that Punjabi issues and even Punjabi language actually takes control of the shows at times. Almost always, issues that are so crucial to the smaller provinces, like those in Balochistan, are never discussed and people from those provinces are ubiquitous because of their absence in these shows. We don’t hear their voiices, dont’t get to know their concerns and views. I have yet to see people that I am really interested to hear in these shows.

Hamid Mir, Dr. Shahid and others of your ilk, how about inviting Rasool Bakhsh Palejo, Atta Ullah Mengal, Mehmood Khan Achakzai, Sardar Marri, Dr. Abdul Hayee Baloch et.el., to your shows just for a change? After all, they are also Pakistanis, belong to a provincial unit of the country, and are well known political figures in their respective constituencies, even if they are unknown in Punjab and irrelevent to the Punjabi elites whose, often vulgar, voices get so much coverage on your channels. Your acts of ommission in this regard, nay, your pathological indifference, to the concerns of the smaller provinces and the voices of their political figures is just another sign of an ugly phenomenon that has an ignoble history in Punjab in particular and in Pakistan in general. Remember the tragedy of 1971 and the “internally colonized” Bengalis? Learn something from your history and, for once, do the just and right thing!

Hamid Mir could very easily have invited some Musharaf hack for propaganda purposes and brownie points but he chose not to do that. I haven’t given up on Hamid Mir as yet… he still has his mojo in my opinion.