l Meray Mutabiq – 24 December 07 | Pakistan Politics
{ 35 comments... read them below or add one }

  • Dervaish said:

    Hassan Nisar spot on! Brilliant analysis. You’ve got it right and in clearly talking about the situation you have successfully cut through the consciously created obfuscations, for which people Dr. Shahid and Hamid Mir are also now, sadly, responsible: the Geo anchors are now safe and harmless for the tyrrany of the day. You, Hassan Nisar, steal the show in this episode of Merey Mutabiq. Just to say these things and do it so clearly and boldly like you do, in these times of universal deciet (to quote Orwell), is a revolutionary act.

  • junaid said:

    nice intro by dr. shahid. although, hasan nisar portrayed reality of the overall corrupted scenario. more lootings and chor leaders.
    boycott election, boycott dakoos.

  • peace said:

    I think in coming months we shud really expect some change in overall scenario of pakistan…….may some type of revolution resulting in the emergence of new leadership

  • ajnabi larki from canada said:

    main too kehtee hoon kay doctor sahib bikk chukay hain. bhlaa daikhoo too iss kay munn say chief justice ya judiciary ka word takk nahin nikklaa pooray programmee say. agar main iss ke jaghaa hottee too chief justice ka swaal lazim poochtee hasan nisaar say.

  • mya said:

    if GEO/Dr Shahid Masood have to bow down eventually then why did they resist initially? we are a nation without heros. Everyone we hope that he/she will be our new hero, falls down and disoppoint us too. i am very very much disoppointed. Dr shahid should have started practicing his medical profession rather than come up with this new “BOW DOWN” way. he’s nothing without his honest analysis.

  • universal007 said:

    we are not a nation.we are a crowd ,we are crowd where people have no tolerance,no respect for each others.we are not willing to change ourselves and look at ourselves and our responsibilities and we expect that we will recieve everything without any strugge.when we go out we dont have any task in our mind why we are going out to support some body.we just do nothing and expect that some angel or one person will change everything and give us everything what we want.

  • yaqub2005 said:

    See Public Gathering when willing and free people are present
    http://www.express.com.pk/images/NP_LHE/20071219/Sub_Images/1100318594-1.jpg
    attentive and lively.

    and now a public gathering when selected and unwilling people are present.
    http://www.express.com.pk/epaper/PoPupwindow.aspx?newsID=1100318592&Issue=NP_LHE&Date=20071219
    dull and unconcerned. looking here and there.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    Guys enough media trial of mainstream and genuine political parties.
    This program of SM is unfortunately a pessimistic program to malign politicians.
    I am a great fan of SM and HM , but off late they have become in sensitive

    Qudrat Ullah Shahab ONCE said that these ruling elites( I mean ruling Khakis) have always tried to malign politicians. And present day Ayub is doing the same thing.

    Look AT HASAN NISAR, talking about a wave of inflation after election. How will staying away from the process control it? Will Farishtas come to improve it.
    Does anyone has CHIRAGH of ALADIN
    .
    The answer is democracy ad more democracy. In difficult times media anchorpersons that have become champions of morality, have themselves shown a low standard.
    Why not learn form India. They have same kind of corrupt politicians, but they have gone through continuous process without army interference. Please be realistic. Anchorpersons like Talat Hussain, Javed Malik are doing a much better job.

    DO vote for parties with popular support. But oppose Political orphans.
    Has establishment given a n elected govt., more than 2 years. People of Pakistan ON ELECTION DAYS IN PAST have gup shup in loving rooms, eating Pakoras having tea and saying SUB CORRUPT HAIN. What a hypocrisy. Why don’t they go and vote and then , someone as right to criticize.
    Give provincial autonomy.

    I agree with one of the comments, these programs should invite gusts from all over the Pakistan. Why not invite some one from Gawadar, Turbat, Kashmor, Tank , Pakpattan.

    This last program of Dr. sahib was not all balanced. Maximum time was given to useless Hasan Nisar. Can Hasan give some solutions. Points to think

  • Aleem said:

    HMMMMMMMMM,,,,

    In my opinion, Pakistan is not a free state until now, we are still living in a slavary system, we are still colonised by the british and americans…. although they are not in our land but their agents in the shape of some families and in tern of some generals of pakistan army still ruling in our country…..

    I think we no need to so called democaracy, we need revolution purely by the publich,,,,,,, to developed the system in our country…..
    how can we say, these are elections, these are not elections just propoganda,, just cartoon program,,, we already have one nonelected president in our country for next 5 years. very funny right????/ hahah
    I can’t say something about my beloved country, indeed it is really in miserable condition… May ALLAH bless our country and our people.
    Ameen.

  • bechari-awam said:

    Hassan Nisar is the biggest l0ta. He used to work for express and was very critical of the chaudaries and company. he then moved to jang and now he is speaking govt language. Now his fiery criticism is against any body standing in the way of chaudries, with few sugar coated mild words about l0ta league to pretend being a fair guy.

  • Asif said:

    Without using the word boycott, Dr. Shahid Masood conveyed a very clear message through analysts the lack of interest of the people for these sham selections.
    Well done.

  • omar said:

    @bechari-awam

    Although i am not a big fan of Hassan Nisar, but i humbly disagree with your comment. He portrayed an ugly picture but i am afraid, thats what it is. If not all, he is 90% right about the current situation.

  • yaqub2005 said:

    Real culprit are those who sit at home due to their laziness and do not vote and then cry about every bodyis corrupt. These are the agents of GHQ.

    If people think that sitting at home and abusing all politician can solve their problems then they are mistaken.

    Let us vote for a change.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    @ yaqub2005

    The nation has to participate in the system.
    Jinnah got pakistan with the help these same sardars, nawabs, maliks. He aprtcipated in elections in 1946 under same tense situation. Mullahs AND SO CALLED LIBERALS were against hin as well.
    IF somene dotn vote then, you shoudl cry foul against politicinans.
    This is what minitary dictators want, to bring so much propaganda against politicinas, so that they can bring their own system.
    There is no harm in another election in 6 months time. BUT vote against musharaf followers.
    I was amazed to see statement from aitzaz, asking army cheif to intervene. One should no do this mistake. Please dont bring army into the system.
    How will boycott solve the inflation, develop an independent election commision.
    I am sorryto say but the the people of pakistan( mostly educated) are part of the problem.
    The educated ave harmed this country then anyone else.
    God save our country

  • Asif said:

    …………………….“People should stay at homes on Jan 8 and foil the fraud with the nation being committed by President Pervez Musharraf who is himself an illegal and unconstitutional president,â€? Mr Achakzai said. He paid tribute to over 60 sacked judges of superior courts who, he said, had been suffering for having refused to take oath under the PCO…………………….

    http://www.dawn.com/2007/12/25/top13.htm

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    @ YAQUB2005
    I
    I agree with you

  • Asif said:

    The cycle of politics continues

    http://www.dawn.com/2007/12/25/ed.htm#4

    …………………………………After some indecision, the best the PML-N has been able to do is to field Omar Sohail Zia Butt, a close relative of the Sharifs, from the constituency. The young Butt might still pull if off on the strength of the PML-N vote bank — a vote bank that will be difficult to retain in the long run without the traditional backing from the visible business community. Mian Saheb has a case to move against copyright infringement. His opponents are employing his tactics against him.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    I have lived in this area NA 126 for some time. But dont know this for last 5 years.
    But atleast Omar butt is loyal to his party. I have seen ery good election campign in 1993 and 1997 in a peaceful manner.
    IF overwhelming majority needs Q / pro musharraf people, then let this nation suffer.
    But the SM program and hasan nisar are useless without any hope.
    Atleast TALAT hussain with youth( future of pakistan) gives me hope.

    I strongly condemn AITZAZ statement inviting army cheif for help. This is what boycott people want, than i am sorry t say this is hopeless.
    Ther is no role of army in politics.

  • GM said:

    @ Asif

    please do not try to post irrelevant comments here.
    either u shud post this comment under Guestimate ( Elections) or for views n News for respective date ( becasue that is meant for general discussion, not related to aa specific video topic)

    Thanks

  • nisarahmad71 said:

    well done Hasan Nisar …. you are bluntly and good analytical speaker.

  • Asif said:

    @GM

    Please move these comments to the current date. Thanks

  • aftab said:

    What a great program. I really appreciate Dr. Shahid Masood for this analysis. Mr. Hassan Nisar is right to predict the out come of this election. People of Pakistan are really sick and tired of this dirty politics by mafia. There woud be more instabilty after election and this is what Mushraf wants. He would not like to have a strong government by one party that would challenge him or his authority. One thing that was missing in this pogram was about question of restoration of judiciary or judges. I have not seen any program that had fucused on this the most importnat issue.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    Hasan NISAR should give solutions to the problems.

  • yaqub2005 said:

    While many peace loving people are not willing to participate in voilent demostration, they have a way to make a difference through peaceful means and that is
    GOING OUT & VOTING on JAN 8 FOR GOOD PARTIES AND CANDIDATES.

    we have secret ballot system, so no need to worry and stamp asper your conscience.

    If I have to wait in a que for few minutes to vote and it can make a difference to bring a change then I should vote.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    @ yaqub2005

    I agree with you.
    I have voted in 1993 and 1997 . INSIDE the both there is no one. You are free their to cast your vote.

  • yaqub2005 said:

    MSUH and his associate’s propaganda machinery has many ways to divert the attention from real issues.

    What was Q league, MQM and MUSH doing for last 5-8 yrs in power. Promoting US cause. MUSH is symbol of BUSH here and also his associates.

    Whoever votes for Cycle League and Kite will vote for MUSH in other words BUSH. People are tired of GREATER NATIONAL INTEREST and need true leaders from AWAM not from GHQ.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    I think this article is just an attempt to tame GEO completly.
    What about musharaf/ q league , they are not acting on forign agenda.

    I THINK MEDIA SHOULD BCOME MOE RESPOSIBLE AND BALANCE.
    Below the belt remarks by partcipants on tv should be deleted.

  • Democat Pakistani said:

    What is wrong with KH, SM AND HM getting good salaries.
    IF we are getting good packages in US AND CANADA ,are we following ther agenda. These salaries are for profssional capiblilities.

    Mush IS occupying president hous and army house at the same time. What is the budget for these each month.
    Why restrictions on all institutions except one. Why ne sacred cow.
    Enough of propaganda through fake and doctored articles

  • javed said:

    i agree wih yaqub2005.
    we have o be responsible ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
    ………………………………………………oherwise i will be toolate..
    …………………………..look at lebonan………. situation

  • amujtaba said:

    OK I agree with Hasan Nisar and Shahid Masood, things are bad; the political leaders are corrupt, Generals are strong, people are insensitive, inflation is rampant, injustice is the order of the day. But here is the million dollar question, what do you braniacs want us dumb commoners to do? Don’t you think an Iqbal/Jinnah model works better than writing another tear jerker like Musaddas Mad o Jazr-e-Pakistan. Get out and start acting, motivate people not just push them deeper into despair. Remember it was the same common,insensitive, ignorant moving watching, music listening bipeds that fought tooth and nail to get you back on air.

  • bechari-awam said:

    @amujtaba
    I have exactly the same contention against these so-called analysts. they have a big mouth when they are expressing their views but once it come to solution they are as much dumb-founded as others. I have a problem with Hassan Nisar that he try to be too smart with his predictions. he is trying to disheart public that there will be no change after elections so please don’t bother to come to vote and just take care of your roti tukkar and leave govt matters to the elite. Hassan nisar especially blame islam for all the problems what muslims are facing today. he is ready to bow in front of the west for being the source of industrial revolution of the 20th century again providing no solution to the problem and just spreading pessimism.

  • Shaz said:

    http://dawn.com/2007/12/26/SlideShow/pic14.jpg

    From where they get the electricity to lit their every night function (because big brother can’t get up early in UK to address the gathering in Paksitan). These Electricity theifs are responsible for CHOAS in Karachi. Why anyone in any of the TV show dont ask this question along with the funding for Big bahi expenses in UK? See the News and Jang, filled with the stories of Bahi logs everyday. Shame on Jang Group

  • jalal said:

    guys you must watch this video just click on the address below or copy this address and paste into the address bar to watch it… must watch please.and also ask every 1 else to to watch this…. its time to change the country and your efforts can change pakistan if you are sincere…

    http://www.teeth. com.pk/blog/ 2007/11/25/ missing-in-pakistan-documentary/

    thank you

  • jalal said:

    m sorry guys the address above was wrong 1…. my mistake…. this is the real 1

    http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-854791386997728455&hl=en-CA

    thank you….

  • GM said:

    @jalal ,

    this video is already available on this website, i mean PkPolitics.
    Also a downloadable version is available. Go through archives and u can find there.

    http://pkpolitics.com/2007/11/28/missing-in-pakistan/

Leave your response!

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Username


Password


Recent Comments
Blog Comments
Search