I didn’t know Fiqh teaches us to quit your principles and support Opportunist, corrupt and incompetent persons. And while criticising every other party but not exposing the ills created by their partner.

I thought Islam teaches to stand by your principles of truth even if your father or brother or ANY ONE has to be sacrificed and do not compromise on any excuse.

In my second question, I was not saying why JI is defending itself if attack by anyone. But I meant, why it is involved in Dada giri, bhatta khori, corruption in academics and imposing their choice of drink against the rest of the students most of which are neutral and have never harmed JI or any other party.

I don’t have any proof beside news from multiple signals that, JI has been widely funded by Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries.

I was not saying being oldest party MEANS you have to have largest vote bank, but I just wanted to ask what are the reasons that despite being oldest party it has not been able to effectively propagate its message. I was asking because being oldest party you are most likely to have better stategies based on your experience. But I think understand your point of view on this issue.

You have got all the historical facts muddled up. Perhaps you are too young (or too old) to remember the facts right. I that case please read a book on history before making a comment.

Dear Fahim
1)There is a Qaida in fiqh that in order to get rid of Big Harm you can accept smaller harm, so dealing FazulRAhman was just like that plus just see the amount of good achieved after uniting all those religious parties and groups who were known to not even prayer behind each other. At least month of Muharam goes Peacefully now.
2)Dirty politics is being done by MQM so if some one shoots you or beat you to death don’t you have a right to defend. i think islam also gives you that right.
3)There is no foreign funding what so ever that i am aware off, if you have any proofs please bring them on. They operate on a system called “I’anat” collected from their workers.
4)Being an oldest party doesn’t qualify you to have vote bank. Look at the people who vote in pakistan, every one is tied in one way or another with biradree system, people are uneducated and poor, they don’t even know who is good or bad and if some time they know they can’t vote according to their will b/c Sardar, Malak, Sain,Makhdoom,Pir etc etc has told to vote them to a particular person. JI need to awaken their Shaoor in this regard which is what they are working.

My question to JI:

1- How can they tolerate a personality like Maulana Fazlurehman?

2- Why they carry out same dirty student politics in Karachi and Lahore, as done by MQM (terrorist group)

3- Why do they rely on foreign funding (esp. KSA) for their political structure?

4- Probably being the oldest party in country, why it hasn’t been able to establish its vote bank nationwide?

But when we see that the main motive of JI is to provide a poise and God fearing leadership to the peple, so that they can serve them in all fields and establish an Islamic rule.
To achieve this goal different options were adopted in last many years, different coalitions were made, MMA is a recent example (which JI tried a lot to save but there were people in MMA, whom purpose is only IQTIDAAR……everyone knows abt them) .

So JI joined or made the alliances for a cause, for justice, for Islamic law and so..but when those are not achieved then there is no meaning to stick with those people.

If we see all these events in this context (and be neutral), it might help to clear some confusions about JI.

JI is proud on having highest educated people (material education religious) in its ranks and that makes it a unique party in Pakistan. People who doubt this statement can verfy the facts at least about leadership, which can be easily collected. Track record shows that JI always performed very nicely in educated areas (if they have any cadidate there) but unfortunately our political syetem has many flwas.

Regarding judiciary, and some other issues…..its a long debate and i will try to respond…but i request the interested readers to visit in detail;

http://www.tarjumanulquran.org
http://www.jammat.org

to have a clear idea about JI policies and future agenda.

Regards

I wonder why they did not hold any long march against musharraf.

Then
Why they paticipated in 2002 elections ?

Does JI has any principle ?