Comments on: Capital Talk – 29 March 2008

By: Safdarkhan

Safdarkhan — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 15:40:06 +0000

@Tanweer Amjad

Capital Talk is Hamid Mir show NOT Tanweer Amjad show; It is upto the host to select his guests and we as audience should respect his selection. If you don’t like the show, simply change the channel. We live in a free and democratic world and we must tolerate other’s views and respect opnion. MQM candidates received big number of votes far bigger than ANP. Educated people of Karachi have far more political insight and wisdom so stop insulting people of urban Sind.

By: Tanweer Amjad

Tanweer Amjad — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 06:44:02 +0000

My previous comment awaiting moderation
… In fact I feel PPP is completely in a fix. They want judiciary NOT to be restored, and they are worried how they are gonna STOP that.

By: Tanweer Amjad

Tanweer Amjad — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 06:41:28 +0000

I think Hamid Mir should show his regard to the audience by not inviting people like Faisal Saleh Hayat. I wonder how people could tolerate his primary school level reasons. He is absolutely ridiculing his party and exposing Musharraf’s choice of politicians with him. Either HM should invite people like Mushahid Hussain to defend their party or strip them over here through their silly stupid shameless answers.
MQM represents Pakistan far less than ANP, since ANP is in more than one province and is in more than two cities. Getting hold of two big cities through weapons doesn’t mean that it is a party of the masses.
Sherry Rehman should feel somewhat ashamed of either her past or of the present. I suppose she is the spokespersonof the party more than Farhatullah Babar. Every one including the religious scholars criticize openly, in fact delivered fatwa against the mode of action by the Lal Masjid and Jamia Hafsa administration, but based on that, massacre of women and children by inviting Pakistan Army can never be defended. Sources of Police say that it was a police task, and they could have handled it themselves. When you try to twist things, you get fully exposed.

By: Optimist

Optimist — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 03:14:08 +0000

@ Pessimist

Don’t force me to say what you deserve.

May Allah give you some Ghairat and you understand that when someone repeatedly tells you to leave them alone, you should do that. Dragging Allah’s name as a taunt will not save you from his wrath. You are not any less Be-ghairat than Musharraf.

By: Pessimist

Pessimist — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 01:06:42 +0000

HEH – I though so…

MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU

By: Optimist

Optimist — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 00:35:42 +0000

@ pessimist

The reason I don’t answer you is that I don’t read people like you. I just read one or two lines and if the person is rude like you, I just ignore his post and write general things (such as Mullahs).

you don’t even deserve that so I requested you not to address me.

plz spare me your …..

By: Pessimist

Pessimist — Tue, 01 Apr 2008 00:03:02 +0000

@Optimist

“He believes that Christain/Jews cannot be our friends and since Quran didn’t mention Hindus, they can be our friends”

Reply if you want to but ill just clear the misconception.

He believes that Ahl-e-Kitab cannot be our ‘HELPERS/AULIYA’ (somthing more than just friends), and then the question posed was can we have defence agreements with Hindus and he replied that from an Islamic point of view this would not be objectionable.

By: Pessimist

Pessimist — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 23:58:48 +0000

@ Optimist

You dont have an answer so youll just try and avoid what I wrote. I have noticed that again and again and again so I can understand.

@TK
Dr Israr was giving a talk on Khalifah in the current global scenario and was invited by some Shiities.

Plus he has problems in his Spinal cord – the disks are fractured plus his knees are also artificial.
So no possibliy of sitting with the rest of the people

By: Optimist

Optimist — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 20:53:29 +0000

@ TK

Dr Israr is one of those who had to leave JI in 1957 because Modoodi wanted to run his own show.

Most of those who left, opened their own ‘shop’. Most of them failed and left terrible sects, such as Tawheedi sect (or Yazeedi sect).

This guy was MBBS doctor. He introduced specialty of Hizb Ut Tehrir in Pakistan. Sharif family supported him but later realised his extreme views and abandoned him. But, like Tahir ul Qadri’ it was too late and the guy had had media exposure.

He believes that Christain/Jews cannot be our friends and since Quran didn’t mention Hindus, they can be our friends. His literal following has led him to believe that we have to make our minorities second class citizens and have defense agreements with Hindu India.

What he didn’t explain was what will India do with us when we declare non-Muslims as second class citizens. When Jawab Deh host challenged him , he said he doesn’t ‘care’ if the whole world declares Muslims second rate citizens.

By: TK

TK — Mon, 31 Mar 2008 20:44:49 +0000

@Optimist: that guy seems to dislike Altaf but likes the fascistic methods used by them. I don’t know much about this Israr guy.. Just looking at this video, why would he not sit down with the rest of the people?

Hazoor never let anyone stand up when he entered their company. He never sat above them except when giving the Khutba. I think in general company, he disliked the norms of VIP’s distinguishing themselves by sitting higher than the ‘ruffians’

I would expect him to sit with the rest of the people, unless of course he has a medical condition or somehting.