Comments on: Live With Talat – 30 November 2009

By: fzaman

fzaman — Fri, 04 Dec 2009 14:00:38 +0000

Live with Talat program on 31/11/09 with different Anchors, was very ill judged. Co-Anchors also were forming unsubstantiated opinions and had exposed themselves to be non wiser than the people they suppose to expose. Hamid Mir was accused of lying by the lady, when he stated that lady was present at certain meeting, which she refuted. They also talk over each which no body can under-stand. My advice to them is. Wise one speaks because he has something to say, Unwise speaks because he have to say something.

In my opinion, unfortunately this program has given fuel to Mr Zardari’s comment of political actors interfering with politics. The Moral duty of a journalist is to read between the lines and find the truth for the public at large, when opinion and facts are mixed by a journalist, surly credibility is lost.

The difference between literature and journalism is that journalism is unreadable and literature is not read. I care and respect of the talk shows, which have become voice of the voiceless. Most of the main Anchors’ were present at this show and have failed their audience.

As far as Mr Talat is concerned, he comes across as right wing nationalist, without considering that Pakistan is surviving beyond its means with its corrupt and incompetent leaders going around with the begging bowl in their hands, beggars can never be choosers. Mr Talat is living in a dream world.

By: Bismil

Bismil — Wed, 02 Dec 2009 22:11:10 +0000

Totally agree with Khurram Mushtaq sb. The only solution of all our issues is ISLAM (total submission to Allah) because “khas hai tarkeeb main qoum-e- rasool-e hashmi”. I believe tha whole humanity is gradually moving towards Islam. It is our duty to learn and teach Islam by understanding Quran or be prepared to face even worst

By: anna

anna — Wed, 02 Dec 2009 19:55:47 +0000

Very Impressive Discussion & very Logical Conclusion drawn by our Media Heroes !
Nusrat Javed showed ever Lasting Maturity.

By: geopakistan

geopakistan — Wed, 02 Dec 2009 11:47:21 +0000

ZARDARI said in his 1st speach.KASHMIR key barey ma koom ko good news.BENAZER key kataloo ka pata hey.ECT ECT what a nonsence .U r a Prezedence of pakistan .Not a Joker? ALLAH BLESS PAKISTAN & ALL OF US

By: mouji

mouji — Wed, 02 Dec 2009 02:38:40 +0000

Well,
I felt ashamed viewing this lot of key journalists. No body had clue about the dynamics of pakistani politics, its directions, conventions and norms except Waheed and Nusrat.
I had no idea that all of these key journalist are fools. Looks like they are prepared and rehearsed for their programs.
I have noticed:
Not a single person had a good grasp of underlying variable and their effect.
Even with their non sense opinion, they did not know how to participate. I would give more then double marks Sh. Rashid, Kaira, Ayaz Amer even to Abid Sher Ali then these rehearsed journalists.
Hamid Mir should be rather called most stupid, then Kashif, Mushtaq, Nasim, Tallat.
Would you believe Tallat’s performance in conducting this show. Just compare this guy with Khurshid Nadeem (program ALAF).
I assessment is these guys are stooges and have no view of their own, they speak only what they are rehearsed and told to speak.
I know it is not pleasant to know all this, it was for me to but this the truth. This may be because this is first lot of anchors we have, they may not be as good as we have in print journalism.

By: dara

dara — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 16:58:24 +0000

They all talk about establishment as if they all get briefing from establishment. Nusrat Javaid has shown again that he is mature out of the lot. He was spot on when he asked about Kery louger Bill, now when the money will come in in Jan , how come establishment could make this as an issue to topple Zardari? also his questions about military aid for fighting in Waziristan and his valed questions about PM Gillani.
Nusrat was correct when he raised the question about Gillani that he exercise his right when ever he likes but when it comes to article 6 and so on he pretends that he has no powers. PM Gillani thought that he could decieve the nation by siding with Establishment, but that will not be hidden any more.
There are some more questions no anchor or journalist has courege to ask.
Q1. What was the role of Gen Kiani in formation of NRO?
Q2. What was the stand of Courp commanders at Musharaf’s trail?
Q3. What was the role of army establishment on judiciary re instatement?
There are some other questions, but we need real and straight forward journalists to ask those questions.

By: aftab

aftab — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 16:21:02 +0000

I hate it when they interrupt each other, i think HM was being sarcastic about Zardari wanting article six for Mushy.

By: china786

china786 — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 14:52:48 +0000

Good show but people r right that these people r assets of Pak and they shouldn’t get together like this as Zardari Maffia is hell bent on getting rid of them. Talat is superb as a guest especially with Kashif Abbasi. I sometime wonder do they realize that they r heroes of Pak and people love them. Nusrat and Hamid Mir spoke more but with little substance while Waheed Hussain was most impressive. Wish the host of Kal Tak was there too. Anyway v good and impressive program.

By: zoommax

zoommax — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 12:16:41 +0000

hamid mir zardari ki side q lay raha hai?
hamid mir k barray main aik joke hai k ye muhallay ka wo sharir larka hai jis nay har larki par ilzaam laga hai hahaha
es ka pata hii nahi chalta k ye kiss side par hai
mere khayal main ye wahi bolta hai jo dusrray nahi boolte

By: akhurshid

akhurshid — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 10:29:32 +0000

i think Talat Hussain and Kashif Abbasi should be guest more often than being hosts as they speak more openly when they are guests, specially Talat Hussain. May Allah protect them from any harm.