PKPolitics Discuss » Current Issues

A letter from Bangladesh on the Egyptian protests

(26 posts)
  1. Revivalist
    member

    A letter from Bangladesh on the Egyptian protests: America and the west can't deceive us again

    Saturday, 05 February 2011 10:53 Jafar Muhammad Abu Abdullah .

    Let me begin by praising Allah سبحانه وتعالى, who has control over all the affairs.

    The story of Tunis and subsequently Egypt, Algeria, Yemen, Jordan and the increasing domino effect in the ummah in the greater Arab world is unprecedented for decades. There are many who say that the people in Tunisia have shown and reinstalled a new hope and dignity in the masses across the Middle East to go on the street and protest, put pressure and then topple their regime. There are many who are saying that the fear factor amongst the general people has wiped out and now they are ready to take the matter in their own hands. However, most of us agree that the Middle East we have seen for the last 60 or 70 years has changed once and for all. Just months ago who could have imagined such a reality in the street of Tunis, Egypt, Yemen, and other parts of the middle east. Indeed it is the beginning of the end of tyrants and the servants of America and the western world insha'Allah.

    Realities in Tunisia

    Once Ben Ali left the country, his loyal friend Mohamed Ghannouchi, formed the government with the same old faces along with bringing certain cosmetic changes in the so called unity government. The government of Ghannouchi has appointed ministers loyal to Ben Ali in key ministries including interior, foreign, finance and information. Thus in reality the cronies of Ben Ali have maintained the "continuity" of his rule and the rule of his party after him, even after he was sacked and became a fugitive! But the people continued with the demand. Still they are on the street, looking forward to Ghannouchi leaving and establishing a radical new system of governance. Interestingly America during this whole part of Jasmine Revolution has remained silent. Ben Ali was a pro-western man, working as an obedient slave to repress the people. His government was very much in the forefront of the American war on Islam. In June 2010 Gen. William E. Ward, Commander, U.S. AFRICOM was in Tunisia to discuss how to deepen their crusade against Islam.

    After remaining silent for about a week, America has now come up with dubious tactics. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called Tunisian Prime Minister Mohammed Ghannouchi on 23rd January to express continued support for the people of Tunisia and hijacked the people movements calling it a desire for a more democratic society. To be honest the US does not have any loyal puppets to project as a new face in Tunisia. That's why even though every single person in a county which is almost 100% Muslim wants Ghannouchi to leave, America is saying that they support the effort of the so called government of unity, perhaps America can find or create a puppet for her within the new formed government of unity. Moreover Hilary has reiterated that America stands ready to assist the Tunisian people to meet the challenges ahead, and assured the Prime Minister that the United States will stand with them as they chart a new course for their country. Thus America truly presented the hypocrisy on its part.

    Realities in Egypt

    The realities in Egypt are quite extraordinary. Just months back there was an election, which had been completely rigged. The government of Egypt led by Hosni Mubarak (considered as man of stability by Obama and America for the region) has been running this country for more than three decades with emergency rules and suppressing people's rights to voice concerns about things like food, clothing, shelter, employment, education and health. Being one of the richest countries in the Arab region, the Egyptian ruler is simply an iconic Pharaoh from every angle. The Tunisian inspired mass protest for the last few days has found a new dimension last Friday where thousands of demonstrators took to the streets with only one demand i.e. down with this regime'. More than a thousand have been arrested and already 100 plus have been killed. The ruling party headquarters has been set ablaze. Mubarak after two days of silence has disbanded the government without stepping down. He is expected to announce a new government. This is something he has done so many times before. But the demand of the people is oneGo Mubarak go!'

    In these extraordinary circumstances there comes America calling Mubarak to listen to people's demands. However they still maintained that Hosni Mubarak's government is stable. Hilary Clinton said that, violence is not the answer for Egypt's grievances while Obama just after the nationwide address of Mubarak said that, `United States will continue to stand up for the rights of the Egyptian people and work with their government in pursuit of a future that is more just, more free, and more hopeful'. Honestly this is similar to what has been America's response to Tunisia.

    Some Uncertain Questions

    While the ummah in Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and elsewhere in the region are calling for radical change, the western world is trying to hijack the fruits of these movements by misdirecting the discussion through their media and other means at their disposal.

    First of all they are labeling these extraordinary demonstrations as evidence of democratic aspiration in the Middle East, while they are the ones who caused and inflicted these tyrants upon the ummah in the greater Middle East and elsewhere in the Muslim world.

    Ben Ali, Hosni Mubarak, Ali Abdullah Saleh and the rest of the rulers in the Muslims word all are tyrants with whom Washington and Europe have been conducting business and looting the wealth of the ummah. These rulers are the ones who supported America and her allies in their crusade against Islam and suppression of political Islam, the natural aspiration of the ummah. The ummah is fed up with the democratization of Iraq and Afghanistan in the last 10 years of occupation. The Muslim ummah knows the crimes of democratic Israel where it clearly exposed the true intention of the western democratic call.

    Therefore, the people in Egypt, Tunisia, Yemen and elsewhere in the region are not calling for democracy rather for a system of governance where the ruler will be accountable to them, not to America and the western powers. The people are looking for their abundant resources to be used for their economic opportunities rather than increasing the bank balances of the rulers and western multinationals. The people are calling for a system that does not protect the interests of Israel in the form of a so-called peace treaty with this Zionist regime, rather the ummah wants to see the Egyptian army go forward into Gaza and end the seize and liberate Palestine once and for all. They want the marriage between leaders of their lands and western colonial powers to be completely cut off. That is their demands. Thus the demand of the ummah is the return of Islam. America knows it very well. In fact in a number of surveys including the Pew Corporation for `world public opinion' showed that more than 85% have voiced their demand for the return of Islam in their practical life. They want colonial politics to end once for all.

    Moreover, the Muslims in Egypt, Tunisia and Yemen know how democracy brings about the same old faces in more legitimate ways to serve America and the west. It is not just that, the ummah understands that democracy is a factory that produces paid and non-paid agents for the west on a continuous basis.

    Let's take the example of Bangladesh, the third largest Muslim country in the world, popularly leveled as a moderate Muslim democracy'. In 1990 a popular uprising toppled a US backed military ruler General Ershad. However, the promise of reforms, political and economic opportunities and other deceiving words of democracy have in the process of the last 20 years produced rulers who sell the country to polytheist and crusader India-USA-UK for their political survival, while the ummah lives in dire poverty, unemployment and chaos. Moreover with democracy America and western powers were successful in dividing the ummah of Bangladesh into two camps one led by Shiekh Hasina and the other led by Khaleda Zia. Both of these criminals compete against each other to gain power and thus naturally ending up by giving up the resources to the crusaders. The democratic transition has allowed America and other western powers to play with people by bringing one for five years and another for five years. Thus the aspiration for radical and comprehensive change is becoming more difficult. Once people voice opposition for the current Prime Minister America and the west quickly present the opposition as the credible alternative and reshape public memory with their mass media. Thus the Ummah of the Middle East understands why America was quick to label these developments asdemocratic aspiration' and surely they will not fall into the American trap to go through the process for another 20-30 years to understand democracy is hypocrisy. Indeed the ummah understands that `democracy is the system by which politicians ‘rape the public'.

    Today America and the western powers understand that they have no servant left in Tunisia, Egypt or in Yemen. They understand the ramification of the change and the desire of the ummah. Had there been any option at their hands 10% of the protests and demonstrations compared to the current level would have been enough to topple the government of Ben Ali, Mubarak and Saleh. The world has seen so many of those architected by America in the past across the world. However with no opposition except the Islamic political parties like An-Nahda, Muslim Brotherhood, and most importantly transnational pan Islamic Hizb ut Tahrir i.e. the liberation party on the ground and capable to rule the country, the western world understands the stakes.

    The second uncertain question is that, who will rule the country? Who is the man to replace Ben Ali, Mubarak or Saleh? With this question the western media wants to create frustration and a vacuum in the public mindset so that at the end they don't fail by themselves. This is exactly what one American policy maker said a few days ago in Al-Jazeera `let them fail by themselves'. The West thinks that, the Islamic ummah does not have anyone better than these rotten traitors. However, the objective of this question is to distance the ummah from its real political stake holdings and rights. With this question they find an opportunity to bring somebody like El-Baradi for instance in Egypt to take the discussion away from real issues.

    Indeed the ummah of Al-Maghreb and the Arab world today realizes that each of them is capable to run the government. Each one of them in the street understands and believes that, they are far better as rulers than these traitors, the paid agents of America, Europe and Israel. Thus the real issue is not who will rule rather with what they will be ruled. Whether they will be ruled by a different man with the same old policies drafted from Washington with cosmetic changes or they will be ruled by the Quran and Sunnah which not just gives political rights back to people but makes its mandatory on the part of the people to exercise their political rights and account the rulers.

    The issue is not whether Mubarak makes some reforms to answer to legitimate grievances by allowing some economic opportunities; rather they will be ruled by Quran and Sunnah which not just gives economic opportunities so that people can meet their food, bread, clothing, shelter, employment and medical care, rather makes it compulsory on the part of the ruler to fulfill these basic needs rather than calling them as economic opportunities.

    The issue is whether we will be ruled by a democratic system that considers angering the west especially America and the EU as never an option, rather we will be ruled by an Islamic political system where its compulsory on the part of the rulers to anger and constantly weaken the resolve of the western powers to weaken them so that the ummah gets back to its glory and dignity with which they are now on the street.

    The issue is whether America will be successful to inspire and hijack these aspirations of the ummah to bring colonial policies to deceive the ummah or the ummah will remain steadfast to call for a radical comprehensive change in the system and install the Islamic Khilafah system to govern themselves so that the property and resources of the ummah does not fall in to the hands of multinationals or western governments and rulers, rather than fall in to the hands of the ummah to create employment through massive industrialization. The issue is whether the ummah will allow America the opportunities for another time to deceive them whereby the so called friendship treaty between the occupying state of Israel and Egypt continuous to save the split son of the west i.e. Israel or the ummah will have the system that will send the Egyptian army for a morning walk to dismantle the state of Israel and lift the seize of Gaza once and for all. Thus the issue is not the person rather the issue is of principles.

    What should we do?

    The ummah of Tunisia has shown what it means if the people express their khair (goodness) of accounting the tyrants. They have already shown the highest level of enjoining the good and forbidding the evil. Alhamdulillah the domino effect has rocked the capitals of the Arab world. However, for the ummah of the Arab world to again position themselves to lead not just the Muslim world rather the entire world the following things will be of paramount importance.

    1. Make one demand i.e. `Islam and Khilafah is our demand'.

    2. Stay in the streets and pray to Allah like you have shown in Cairo and other parts of Egypt at the time of prayer in jamah to soften the heart and minds of the security forces.

    3. While you are on the street the Islamic political party Hizb ut-Tahrir is having contact with the army to win their support for you. The party has a clear Islamic understanding of the system of Khilafah and they have more than 50 years of experience. Support the party. Call Tahrir from Tahrir square. Understand that indeed the army will play a crucial role in shaping your destiny. Therefore help Hizb ut-Tahrir to win over the support of your army around your side.

    4. Use the mosques across the country to deliver common messages to the public that they want radical change only possible by establishing the Islamic Khilafah system that will fulfill all your dreams like ending the ties and dependencies on America and other colonial countries to empowering your economic and political opportunities.

    5. Never fall into the trap of America and other western foreign powers or their surrogates. Remembers the call for democracy is simply giving America the spider web that slowly but surely will grab you in future like it did in Bangladesh, Indonesia or elsewhere in the Muslim world. Understand that America has no power to militarily intervene in your course. Neither have they had any political tools. Thus now they are crying for human rights and freedom to deceive you.

    6. Never give up by simply listening that there is a credible election announced by the government or interim government or unity government of any kind. Rather make sure that you disconnect all the means of western colonial interferences and install Islam in power. Islam itself has the power to bring about new leaderships.

    7. Prepare the ummah mentally to be tough to lead the ummah of Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم. Surely this is a blessed responsibility.

    8. Pray to Allah as we pray for you from a land far distant from you.

    May Allah grant the ummah the victory that pleases Him سبحانه وتعالى. And may Cairo, Tunis, Sana' or Al-Maghreb be the start of the return of Khilafah ala minhajun Nobuwah.

    Remember what the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said from Al-Nu'man b. Bashir, who said: "We were sitting in the mosque of the Messenger of Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم, and Bashir was a man who did not speak much, so Abu Tha'labah Al-Khashnee came and said: ‘Oh, Bashir bin Sa'ad, have you memorised the words of the Messenger of Allah (saw) regarding the rulers?' Huthayfah replied, ‘I have memorised his words'. So Abu Tha'labah sat down and Huthayfah said, ‘The Messenger of Allah صلى الله عليه وسلم said ‘Prophethood will be amongst you whatever Allah wishes it to be, then He will lift it up if He wished to lift it up. Then there will be a Khilafah on the way of the Prophet, and it will be whatever Allah wishes it to be, then He will lift it up if Allah wished to lift it up. Then there will be an inheritance rule, and it will be whatever Allah wishes it to be, then He will lift it up if He wished to lift it up. Then there will be a coercive rule, and it will be whatever Allah wishes it to be, then He will lift it up if He wished to lift it up. Then there will be a Khilafah on the way of Prophethood.' Then he was silent."

    Jafar Muhammad Abu Abdullah
    Dhaka, Bangladesh (29th January, 2011).

    Posted 1 year ago on 07 Feb 2011 13:17 #
  2. Thank you, Revivalist. That was most instructive nad timely. Also much-needed as an overall view,

    Posted 1 year ago on 07 Feb 2011 14:55 #
  3. Revivalist
    member

    It it indeed a very well written article explaining the reality very well.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 6:48 #
  4. SufiSoul
    Member

    Arabs elected HAMAS in pelsitine despite for their hardships till now.and still standing with hamas...
    when Arab says that west and US cannot decieve us that is true for Arabs....
    This arab nation have a quality that are always at the extreme....at extreme of under dictatorship.....now they will be at extreme of freedom......
    Same as in past they were at extreme of sins,doing naked Tawafe Kaaba.....
    Than after islam at extreme of loyalty with Islam and within no time Islam was taken out of the Arab boundaries to rest of the world....
    Majority of the Arab people cannot survive in middle of the situation....you will find them at extreme always.....

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 6:58 #
  5. Revivalist
    member

    If that is the case then they will return back to Islam again as they have been under extreem dictatorship for over 30 years.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 7:20 #
  6. SufiSoul, I read through your post several times before I finally had to agree that you've given us a most enlightening insight into the Arab character. Thanks.

    The extremes of hardship, the extremes of discipline, the extremes of materialism, the extremes of patience and now, what we are seeing, the extremes of revolt. That should just about be right.

    Revivalist: The day of the Muslim Brotherhood is coming closer with every passing minute. Remember them? The first to stand up for Islam in 1928 already after the fall of the last Ottoman Caliph, the first signal of Muslim revival very shortly after its removal from the so-called course of history. Sure, they are returning to Islam. In fact, they never left Islam. So perhaps the sentence should be modified to: they are returning "openly" to Islam.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 9:07 #
  7. Revivalist
    member

    MG,

    Agree, but the context was of ruling and not Aqeedah wise.. from dictatorship to khilafah.. I hope IM don’t get themselves trapped into the same circle and fill the vacuum just by name sack letting the same dictatorship or democratic dictatorship going. Being an Islamic party their only demand should be to establish Islam as an ideology and should not accept anything less then that…

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 9:23 #
  8. Revivalist, thanks, but hang on. I wasn't talking Aqeedah either, simply political Islam. Give the Brotherhood some time. Back them up to the hilt now and trust them.

    At least I do. They cannot, the way things stand, demand an Islamic State. Do you know how many enemies surround them already? You do know what it means for the Palestinians. I'd much rather they proceeded cautiously.

    Revivalist, think. The highest price for Islam over the past hundred years or so has been paid by whom? Roughly speaking: 1. The Palestiians, 2. The Afghans, 3. The Pakistanis (I refer to the Partition martyrs who made this country possible and who are rarely referred to in the columns of these pages), 4. the Iraqis, 5. the Muslim Brotherhood.

    Give us all time. We're getting there at long last.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 10:08 #
  9. ajhons
    Member

    The days of anti Islam are dying out.So many people embrasing Islam despite the plethora of negative propaganda their media is barkigng out since long and their "Planed atrocities" in every part of the word against muslims.They were hunting like dogs to abolish every single entity that muslim world holds.The fear they had 1400 years ago still haunt them.

    But how they can fight with the Allah,with the fate Allah had already written for them in "Kitab-e Mobeen".Muslims are not united, ruled by their puppets but how long will it take to unite them,how long these puppets can dance on the strings, thirty years, fourty years fifty years.What they failed to ubderstand is the course of nature,Its protocole to govern the universe, its laws to run the natures affairs.

    Egypts,Tunisia is not just the outcome of anger and desperation of some hundred thousand souls.Its the re arranging of the system by nature itself disturbed by the evil of earth.
    "Qustuntunya" army is gearing up to re define the defination humans forget long ago

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 10:36 #
  10. ajhons
    Member

    Khilafat or democracy or autocrasy whatever the governance mod applied everyting has to go throughg a change except the Message descended to us through the noblest of nobles and greats of greats(PBUH).
    The changes we see happening around us and cries of shattered Ummah sometimes distract our faith.The betrayal we experienced in the name of religion or in the name of country is the only reason of our hasten for change.Otherwise Islam is to prvail till the last day when the sun will be overthrown And when the stars will fall

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 10:49 #
  11. toamin
    member

    true, people have been deceived through almost all slogans, socialist came and failed, democratics came failed, dictators came and failed, islam's call was successful in uniting provinces under pakistan but later leaders betrayed this call as well-

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 11:12 #
  12. ajhons
    Member

    We have failed ourselves, brother Salam.How hippocrate we are in our approach that we give every system a chance execpt Islam.You know why we are afraid deep down the heart.We are afraid of our own misdeeds and or own guilt of twisting the facts as they suits us.
    We as a nations failed and we as a leaders failed because we are not yet convinced that Islam is the only solution to our all problems.You will find people talikng about Islamic revolution but their eys will fail to show the spark of their words.

    We fail to see the beauty of Life which it holds in the face of our religion.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 11:23 #
  13. Good, I'm glad we all agree here on essentials. We differ as to details, time factor, straightaway or gradually, etc., but what our final goal is appears absolutely clear to all those of us who have contrinued to this thread so far. Great day!

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 11:42 #
  14. ajhons
    Member

    MG Sir
    we are heading toward a unanimous destination, some knowingly and some unknowingly.We have taken different paths, different stopping plans but we are all for a single point.
    The Renaissance

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 11:56 #
  15. Absolutely, ajhons, absolutely. The Renaissance. The rebirth of the Muslim Nation. Thank you Tunisia, Thank you Egypt, Thank you Iraq, Thank you Afghanistan, Thank you Pakistan and, mainly, Thank you Palestine, Thank you Kashmir.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 15:45 #
  16. I salute Jafar Muhammad Abu Abdullah for writing such comprehensive article. His thoughts and emotions are admirable. I feel sorry that I can not call such people my countryman although we are part of a single ummah the Millat-e-Wahidah.

    Although I love and appreciate every bit of this article, however I have some pessimistic feelings. It may not end in the way we are expecting. Enemies of Islam and Arabs are so cunning, tactful and resourceful that they can neutralize all this effort. I know many friends will not like these comments. But if we analyze it on basis of facts and figure, it seems quite correct, while analyzing it we have to keep emotions apart.

    Posted 1 year ago on 08 Feb 2011 17:24 #
  17. SufiSoul
    Member

    If that is the case then they will return back to Islam again as they have been under extreem dictatorship for over 30 years. ......

    .............................
    I feel very glad when i meet egyption TJ people.during Last haj i travelled with them and we have discussions in this regard.
    It was strange for me how egyptions are COLOURED same like Pakistanis TJ people and we felt no difference and difficulty throughout the HAJ.
    One of the strong character of TJ is always that they greatly respect muslim brothers and specially if someone is already fimiliar with TJ.
    So ISLAM is always and every where the common point between all the muslims.
    You will be wonder HOW in the lands TJ is not allowed to work, local people are working without any fear and despite of STRICT LAWS in this regard..
    I noticed that ARABS still have that quality of BEING AT EXTREME and when we are talking abt results than this nation is best in giving results on either way..
    We,SUB-CONTINENT PEOPLE are always at the MIDDLE and cannot live with the extreme situations.
    Afghanistan people and specially Pashtune belt is having sharing the same quality like Arabs,that they also prefer to live at extreme.
    So by reading the CHARACTER OF ANY NATION it is always benefitial to TAKE ADVANTAGES of their character and policies chalked out to make that nation better able to deal with comming situations..

    Again i would say that ISLAM is the only slogan made all the muslims united facing each n every challenge.

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 0:31 #
  18. Revivalist
    member

    Dear MG,

    I hope that they will not be trapped in the same circle where they will agree only on a face change. If you see the article the examples of Bangladesh is given in the same context. As for the demand for an Islamic state, it shouldn’t be a demand of IM as its their promise to the people of Egypt and therefore it should the demand of the people from them to remember their promise and not to compromise on it. When such golden opportunity comes they should accelerate the call for an Islamic state for which it is working and making public opinion. If they will agree to the current system like 'MMA' then it is not going to take us anywhere rather we will be providing more and more strength to the system we are actually working to change. Therefore the call and objective should be crystal clear and the party should have all the necessary home work ready for any substantial change.

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 5:06 #
  19. Bangladesh mein khilafat aa gayi jo ab yehi gissi pitti patti egyptians ko parha raha hai yeh banda!!

    Proponents of Khilafat belong to a cult, yes a cult, these sheeple are happy to follow it as if without it Muslims are doomed and somehow in their minds they have conjured up this fantasy that this is one of the pillars of Islam!!!

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 5:32 #
  20. Revivalist
    member

    dell,

    Please growup and say something new... same old rants.... FYI, Khilafah is the ruling system in Islam....

    '...and khilafah will re-establish on the method of prophethood' (Masnad Ahmed)

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 6:01 #
  21. Revivalist, You and I are just engaged in a discussion. The Ikhwan-e-Muslimen and the people of Egypt will have to put in the hard work.

    If Ikhwan can come out and take the reins of power without too much bloodshed, certainly, why not? But as usual I fear for the Palestinians and, to a lesser degree, the Lebanese. Israel hasn't yet been weakened enough to make such a move feasible at this point in time.

    I again plead for moderation in this case. And, Revivalist, where on earth is the need for hurry now? Allah has spoken to the Ummah, hasn't He? Did we need a clearer message than the one we've already received through Tunisia and Egypt?

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 6:16 #
  22. So you are going to follow rather not so authentic "sahih" hadith from a book that has been deemed suspicious by many scholars as the basis of your struggle.

    Islam doesn't need Khilafah to survive. Get your heads out of the sands.

    Islam doesn't have a ruling system, Quran does not mention anywhere to establish Khilafah.

    Quran talks about just, transparent and honest rulers. You guys are just hopeless. Your demagoguery works on poor and uneducated people, that's unfortunate.

    This picture epitomizes what absolute junk Khilafat cult is selling to simpletons in the name of religion.

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 6:25 #
  23. quaidkamazaar
    Member

    @ SufiSoul

    your analysis makes a lot of sense
    i have been around Saudis a lot and they live in extremes as well. it does hold true for almost all Arabs.

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 8:30 #
  24. SufiSoul
    Member

    Islam doesn't have a ruling system, Quran does not mention anywhere to establish Khilafah. ..............

    Where does quran mention democracy about.???If not why you would like to stick to democracy.????

    Posted 1 year ago on 09 Feb 2011 10:33 #
  25. Sufi

    I never said democracy is mentioned in the Quran. Quran talks about fair, transparant and honest ruler. Quran has no concern with what kind of system he some through!!

    Posted 1 year ago on 10 Feb 2011 5:29 #
  26. Revivalist
    member

    dell,

    Do you want me to start the whole episode again? Quran, Sunnah, Ijma of sahaba and opinions of all the classical scholars agree to the obligation of khilafah. Now should we accept them or Mufti Azaam Mr. dell????

    By the way, let us know what is your understanding of khilafah? What is khilafah according to you?

    Posted 1 year ago on 10 Feb 2011 9:30 #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.