PKPolitics Discuss » Social and Cultural Issues

Doctors Hospital killed my 3 Year Old Daughter

(18 posts)
  1. rashidahmed
    Member

    This Story I am posting here on Behalf of Aqeel Malik, Father of Imaane Malik

    On November 29, 2009 at 3 am in the morning my 3 year old daughter, Imanae, spilt hot water on her wrist. My wife and I immediately took her to Doctors Hospital and Medical Center in Johar Town, Lahore. Although it was a very small burn, we chose to go to the hospital as our baby was in a lot of pain and we wanted her hurt to go away as quickly as possible.

    At the hospital we were met by the emergency ward staff, who applied an ointment on her hand and gave her an injection to soothe the pain. When Imanae continued to cry because of the pain, the nurse called the doctor on duty. I noticed when he walked into the room that he had obviously been asleep and had just been woken up.

    The doctor instructed the nurse to give Imanae another injection. Imanae however continued to cry. Fifteen minutes later, the sleepy doctor instructed the nurse to inject Imanae with the 3rd injection. All in all, 5mg of this anesthetic/pain killer was given. This was the moment when my little baby went silent and started losing consciousness. Just before she totally passed out, she started calling out my name and saying that everything was getting blurred and she couldn't see clearly. Little did I know that these were the last words my daughter would ever say.

    I asked the doctor what was happening to my daughter, he assured me that she was FINE and was just SLEEPING, and left the room. I however wasn’t satisfied and checked Imanae myself to see if I could feel her breath or hear her heartbeat.

    When I couldn't feel either of the two, I immediately informed the nurse. She called the doctor again who used a Heart Beat Monitor to examine Imanae. There was no reading on the monitor. I asked the doctor what that signified and he told me that since the monitor was intended for adult use, it could not detect my baby's hear beat. I WISH I HAD ASKED HIM THEN WHY HE WAS USING IT ON MY HELPLESS AND UNCONSCIOUS CHILD AND WASTING PRECIOUS TIME!!!

    At this point, some other doctors present on duty at the hospital joined him as well. They connected Imanae to an ECG machine, but that too also only reported a straight line. My wife asked why the line was straight but the doctors did not reply. They kept on stating that she was fine and was just having some breathing problems. All the doctors present on the scene, started conferring between themselves as they continued to examine her. They continued to ignore our repeated pleas on what was happening to our daughter.

    They then started giving her CPR and it was at this point I realised that my baby's life was in danger. The doctors however kept reassuring us that she was fine. They continued conferring between themselves and I was certain that something had gone horribly wrong. Another 20 or so minutes passed in this torture and confusion. They continued to reassure us that she was ok!! IF SHE WAS OK, WHY WAS THERE NO PULSE ON THE ECG...WHY WAS THERE NO HEARTBEAT...WHY WERE THEY GIVING HER CPR, IF SHE WAS OK.....WHY WHY!!!

    Finally, one of the doctor told me that she was having difficulty breathing and because Doctors Hospital did NOT HAVE a baby Ventilator we should take her to some other hospital before her condition worsened. They suggested we take her either to Ittefaq hospital or to Fatima Memorial, or that we take her to Ward 23 of the Children's Hospital.

    I asked them for an ambulance because she was connected to all kinds of machines, but they told me that the ambulance was not available. However, if we still wanted one...we would have to WAIT for half an hour!!! My baby was not breathing and they wanted me to wait for half an hour!!

    I decided to take my dying Imanae in my own car and pleaded with them to give me a doctor to accompany us to Children's Hospital. I did not know what was wrong with her and wanted someone to come along and explain what exactly her condition was. I wanted a list of injections and other medicines given to her, to give to the doctors at Children's Hospital. I wanted a copy of her ECG report.....

    Nothing was given......and a WARD boy asked to go along.

    It took us 15 minutes to reach Children's Hospital.....where we were told that my 3 year old daughter...my only child...the light of my life...my reason for living...was DEAD!!

    Apparently, I am not the only one who has had his life shattered by this hospital. There are several similar incidents where Doctors Hospital have dumped patients whose treatments they have botched, on to other hospitals.

    One such incident that I came across was reported a few years ago in the Daily Times:

    http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006%5C02%5C12%5Cstory_12-2-2006_pg3_7

    With your help, I have discovered several other cases that strongly indicate malpractice and gross negligence by this hospital.

    If you are a victim of Doctors Hospital or know of someone who suffered at their hands, please let us know so that we can put it forward and bring the culprits to justice.

    Thanks
    Aqeel Malik (Father of Imaane Malik)

    Source http://www.imanae.co.uk/fullstory.html

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 12:09 #
  2. its so disturbing and painful to know that our hospitals are playing with the lives of ppl .

    already ,we are short of medical facilities .
    and the facilities ,which are available are of this standard.

    hospital management should be seriously punished .
    so we can hope ,for other doctors and hospitals to follow their duties ,in a better manner .

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 12:23 #
  3. i am really very sad to read all this matter.

    my full sympathies are with the parents.

    i suggest the culprits/responsible of this incident must be lashed and banned for practicing all his life.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 12:39 #
  4. I consider Imaane Malik as National Icon to trigger a nationwide campaign against the casual and non-professional attitude and inhuman behavior of Health Industry in Pakistan.

    Allah, bless the innocent soul of Imaane Malik. Ameen!

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 13:41 #
  5. I'm gonna second Javedsheikh.

    The pain of Aqeel malik and his wife can only be understood by the parents who has lost a child. When you lost your child you, a part of you is also gone with that.

    I'm with Aqeel malik with all my heart and we all must support him to prevent other unfortunate incidents like this.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 14:02 #
  6. I really want to appreciate Aqeel Malik for doing this effort instead of keeping silent. By this perhaps he could save many flower like child which are killed due to the negligence of doctors in our country.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 14:10 #
  7. Anonymous

    Very sad. I feel sorry for the family.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 14:55 #
  8. It was not a Doctor's Hospital but a dark house of death angles in the form of nonprofessional, unqualified persons posing as doctors who took an innocent life nipping it right in the bud.
    All such so called hospitals be scrutinized and the culprits put behind bars for ever, without a chance of parole so they would never ever be able to inflict harm to anyone anymore.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 15:45 #
  9. jaypk
    Member

    only thn they realize if sumthin similar happens to thr child....my condolence to the grieved family..!!

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 16:48 #
  10. NNL
    member

    From the looks of it the father seems pretty intelligent but somehow has failed to mention what was actually given to teh Girl so that a true cause can be identified.

    Usually hospitals have an internal MMR/Modality& Mortality report.

    A 5mg of Anaesthetic or pain killer is very highly unlikely to cause sudden cessation of breathing or heart beats.

    Its also unlikely that fool on duty gave something more potent than that.

    They need to focus also on the medicines used cos 90% of the times 'jali' medicines are a cause for a lot of things.

    I truly sympathize with the parents and the torment that they are going thru. My prayers are with them.

    Posted 2 years ago on 08 Dec 2009 17:04 #
  11. expakistani
    Member

    very sad news,

    defiantly health care facilities in Pakistan are not up to the standard .... but sometime Doctors are kind of helpless.. ..

    - I dont know if they even ask for any basic information such as allergies etc from patient before giving medication /injections... or should patient provide such information to doctors in advance

    - How about expired / fake medications? Do doctors have any control over such thing?

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 4:16 #
  12. sasherwani
    Members

    Boycott Doctor's Hospital until they fire the guilty staff and give monetary compensation to the dead girl's parents! (even though Ive heard they arent asking for any compensation).

    Boycott them completely!

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 4:28 #
  13. Augustus
    Member

    I don't agree with "Sasherwani". In my opinion Doctors' Hospital must be sealed for 5 years and M.D and administrative staff should be charged under "Attempt to murder" and pharmacy owner and doctor should be hanged for keeping expired medicine. I know many people won't agree with me but i think we should start somewhere. We pay so much to these hospitals and doctors and we don't get the requisit services.

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 5:17 #
  14. sasherwani
    Members

    My emotional friend Augustus,

    The reaction you suggest is an ideal government reaction. What I suggested (boycotting) was more of a public reaction to this insanity.

    Dont keep any hopes from the Govt. Its for sale and Doctor's Hospital Im sure has the money.

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 5:40 #
  15. waqartaurus
    Members

    these private hospitals are robbers, i went to national hospital for vaccination of my 8 months daughter, here after vaccination Dr. made a bill of 5400 Rs. i was shocked. later i asked other friends who have children, and told them about their charges, they were astonished. these private hospitals are not different from robbers. Dr. hospital should be banned from practise. but this is notthe only incident, there have been many incidents like that. Emaane incident was reported in media at proper time. May God curse on all those who are taking lives of innocent.

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 7:45 #
  16. uovervinnelig
    Member

    Very sad, may Allah help her parent to bear this loss.

    What is Mr Shahbaz Sharif is doing? I used to hear that he is very good administrator!!!!!

    Posted 2 years ago on 09 Dec 2009 12:10 #
  17. Where are Khadm e Ala???

    Posted 2 years ago on 11 Dec 2009 6:44 #
  18. So far all of the possible activity against Management of the Hospital has been executed under the directions of the Khadam-i-Ala.

    Better you direct the question towards Medical Association of Pakistan, what actions they have planned to monitor the professionalism of Physicians?

    Posted 2 years ago on 11 Dec 2009 13:35 #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.